Every year, thousands of Australian small business owners face insolvency. Many must navigate two separate legal systems simultaneously - one for their company, another for themselves - at the worst possible time. The cost is not just personal. It is a drag on the entire economy.
When we talk about productivity, we reach for the familiar levers: innovation, skills, infrastructure and tax reform. All matter.
But another productivity lever is hiding in plain sight: regulation that works.
In a dynamic economy, businesses can enter, grow, restructure and, where necessary, exit with relative ease. Capital moves to more productive uses. Entrepreneurs are more willing to take risks because failure, when it occurs, can be resolved efficiently and fairly.
When exit is slow, uncertain or unnecessarily complex, capital and expertise become trapped. Creditors wait longer for recovery. Viable businesses lose opportunities, while failed businesses linger. Entrepreneurship and economic dynamism suffer.
That is why the Productivity Commission’s inquiry into reducing barriers to business dynamism matters. It asks whether Australia’s regulatory settings support the constant renewal of business activity, including what happens when a business can no longer continue.
As Australia’s personal insolvency regulator, the Australian Financial Security Authority (AFSA) sees first-hand where business exit creates friction.
Business-related personal insolvencies account for 30 per cent of new personal insolvency matters, but over 80 per cent of new liabilities. This reflects the way many Australian businesses are structured and financed.
When an incorporated business becomes insolvent, it generally enters the corporate insolvency regime overseen by ASIC. When an unincorporated business, such as a sole trader or partnership, becomes insolvent, they enter the personal insolvency system regulated by AFSA.
In practice, however, the boundary between business and personal debt is rarely neat. Small business owners often secure business loans against personal assets, provide personal guarantees or use household finances to support their enterprise. When the business fails, the owner may need to navigate both systems at once - precisely when they are under the greatest financial and personal stress.
Two systems. Two regulators. Two sets of processes.
The result can lead to confusion, delay and unnecessary cost.
There is also structural duplication. Around 650 registered liquidators administer corporate insolvencies, while just over 200 registered trustees administer personal insolvencies. Most registered trustees are also registered liquidators yet must operate across two distinct regulatory systems.
Creditors face similar friction. A creditor dealing with an insolvent company and its owner may need to pursue separate processes and navigate different rules to recover value from what is, commercially, the same failed enterprise.
These are not simply technical inconveniences. They are productivity costs.
The Treasurer’s terms of reference for the Productivity Commission inquiry recognise that economic renewal depends on both effective restructuring and efficient exit. Viable businesses should have a genuine opportunity to restructure. Businesses that cannot be saved should be able to exit quickly, fairly and at proportionate cost.
Importantly, the inquiry specifically asks whether greater harmonisation of personal and corporate insolvency could deliver net benefits, particularly for small business owners who may need to navigate both systems.
A 2023 parliamentary inquiry identified the same underlying problem: the division between personal and corporate insolvency does not always reflect the operating reality of smaller businesses, where personal and business liabilities are often intertwined.
Internationally, jurisdictions including the United Kingdom, Singapore and New Zealand have already moved toward more integrated and harmonised insolvency frameworks, recognising the economic cost of fragmentation.
Harmonisation does not necessarily require a single regulator or one uniform regime. But it should mean simpler entry points, better coordination, less duplicated registration and reporting, clearer treatment of intertwined debts, and processes designed around the economic reality of small business failure.
The opportunity is clear. Better alignment between personal and corporate insolvency would make it easier to restructure viable businesses, close failed businesses, recover value and redeploy capital.
A modern insolvency framework is not merely a safety net. It is economic infrastructure.
Efficient insolvency systems preserve value where businesses remain viable and allow capital, labour and expertise to be redeployed more quickly when they are not. They enable honest entrepreneurs to recover and try again. They also give creditors greater confidence that losses will be managed transparently and fairly.
That may sound like regulatory housekeeping. In reality, it is practical economic reform: supporting entrepreneurship, strengthening credit markets and lifting productivity.
Insolvency reform is not peripheral to economic growth. It is one of the levers that can help deliver it.